Impress your Valentine with a batch of our Nutter Butter Cookie Hearts. They’re no bake cookies, which is nice. All you’re doing is cutting, microwaving, and decorating. For more sweet treats ...

Surprisingly, it could, and it is. Who knew there could be an even better version of peanut butter sandwich cookies than Nutter Butters? I wouldn't have dreamed such a thing was possible (yes ...

Some of their over-the-top shakes include Nutter Butter cookies, a whole waffle and bacon strips and even an entire slice of cake served right on top of the shake of your choosing. "It’s been ...

Or the Fluffer Nutter, a classic Betty Crocker recipe for peanut butter cookies, but with added marshmallows, elevating them to a nougaty, crunchy, gooey treat. "I want to make it fun and ...

What if I told you he transfused all his blood out for Nutter Butter creme and Nuttani would melt in the summer sun into a puddle but the Guggenheims would do a giveaway where everyone in attendance ...

While a basic cookie, this is one of the staples of the cookie sale. Peanut butter filling is sandwiched between two oatmeal cookies. While some compare it to Nutter Butters, these cookies aren’t as ...

You want cookies and you want them, well, yesterday. Behold, these peanut butter cookies—courtesy of Feel Good Foodie blogger Yumna Jawad—require a mere three (3!) ingredients and take 20 ...

Not all protein powders are created equal. Find out which popular ones are packed with added sugars, artificial ingredients ...

Potbelly isn’t waiting for Valentine’s Day to share a little love with its loyal fans. Instead, the neighborhood sandwich shop is sharing the caring spirit of mid-February early with the introduction ...

Here is every cookie dropping at Crumbl this week, ranked from least essential to most delicious. I once called Crumbl’s Peanut Butter ft. Reese’s Pieces the brand’s “best utilization ...

For the first time ever, M&M'S is adding a Peanut Butter Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich to its line of frozen confections, to be released in conjunction with the holiday on Friday, Jan. 24.